For real estate investors, selling appreciated property can trigger capital gains taxes and depreciation recapture. A Section 1031 exchange allows those taxes to be deferred, preserving more capital for reinvestment, but the rules are technical and must be followed carefully.
Below is a practical overview of how 1031 exchanges work, who may benefit, and where common pitfalls arise.
A 1031 exchange, named after Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code, allows taxpayers to defer capital gains taxes when they sell qualifying investment or business-use real estate and reinvest the proceeds into another qualifying “like-kind” property.
Under current law, 1031 exchanges are limited exclusively to real property held for investment or productive use in a trade or business. Personal residences, property held primarily for resale, and most personal property do not qualify.
The definition of “like-kind” is broad for real estate purposes. In general, investors can exchange one qualifying U.S. real property interest for another, such as multifamily property for commercial property, raw land for industrial property, retail centers for self-storage facilities, or single-family rentals for larger apartment complexes.
Qualifying property must be held for investment or business purposes.
The primary advantage of a 1031 exchange is tax deferral. Instead of paying capital gains taxes and depreciation recapture immediately after a sale, investors can roll their equity into another investment property, preserve more capital, and gain flexibility to reposition holdings, improve cash flow, and support long-term planning objectives.
It can also help investors move into larger or more profitable properties, diversify by geography or asset type, or shift into investments that better match their income needs or management preferences. It may also support long-term estate planning because, under current law, inherited property generally receives a basis adjustment to fair market value at death, which may reduce or eliminate deferred gain depending on the facts and future law. As Ashley Barrett, Partner at TRP Sumner PLLC, notes, “a properly planned 1031 exchange can help investors keep more capital working for them instead of paying a substantial tax bill immediately.”
A 1031 exchange may be especially useful for investors with highly appreciated property, owners looking to simplify or diversify holdings, and taxpayers seeking a more tax-efficient way to reposition their real estate portfolios. It can also appeal to those moving from active property management into more passive investments.
Common replacement properties include rental homes, apartment complexes, office buildings, retail centers, industrial properties, vacant land held for investment, agricultural land, and certain long-term leasehold interests.
By contrast, personal residences, vacation homes held primarily for personal use, property held primarily for resale, and partnership interests generally do not qualify.
Although the concept sounds straightforward, 1031 exchanges are governed by strict IRS requirements and deadlines. Investors generally have 45 calendar days after the transfer of the relinquished property to identify potential replacement properties in writing, and the replacement property generally must be received by the earlier of 180 calendar days after the transfer or the due date of the taxpayer’s return for that year, unless the return is extended. The investor also cannot directly receive or control the sales proceeds, which must be held by a Qualified Intermediary, and any cash received, debt reduction, or non-like-kind property included in the transaction, commonly referred to as “boot,” may create partial taxable gain. As Partner Ashley Barrett notes, “many failed exchanges occur because taxpayers underestimate how strict the timing and procedural requirements are, and even minor missteps can disqualify the transaction and create unexpected tax exposure.”
While 1031 exchanges can offer meaningful tax advantages, they may be less attractive when an investor needs liquidity from the sale proceeds, when suitable replacement properties are limited or overpriced, when the administrative complexity outweighs the tax benefit, or when the investor plans to exit real estate ownership altogether. In some situations, future tax rates or broader investment goals may also favor recognizing gain now rather than continuing to defer it.
Proposals to limit or modify Section 1031 exchanges do surface periodically, but no major federal change to the core real-property-only framework appears to have been enacted as of now.
A 1031 exchange can be a valuable planning tool, but each transaction should be evaluated carefully.
Because each transaction involves legal, tax, and practical considerations, investors should weigh both the opportunities and the tradeoffs carefully. Tax laws and guidance can change, and the right strategy depends on each investor’s specific circumstances, so please check with us before making any decisions related to a 1031 exchange.
Ashley Barrett, CPA, is a Partner at TRP Sumner PLLC, where she advises real estate investors, developers, property owners, and closely held businesses on tax planning, compliance, and strategic financial matters. She works closely with clients to identify opportunities that support growth, improve tax efficiency, and help them navigate the evolving financial and regulatory landscape. Ashley is committed to providing proactive guidance and practical solutions that help clients make informed decisions and achieve their long-term business objectives.
Founded in 1972, TRP Sumner PLLC is a full-service CPA and advisory firm serving businesses, individuals, families, and organizations throughout North Carolina and across the United States. With offices in Fayetteville and Dunn, the firm provides tax, accounting, audit and assurance, and advisory services designed to help clients navigate complexity, manage risk, and achieve long-term success. TRP Sumner is committed to delivering responsive service, practical guidance, and strategic insight tailored to each client's unique goals. Recognized as an Inside Public Accounting Top 400 Firm, a Business North Carolina Best Place to Work, and an Accounting Today Best Firm to Work For, TRP Sumner's commitment to excellence extends to both its clients and its team members. Learn more at www.trpsumner.com.
Join us Sept. 29 for our third Power Breakfast of 2026 as business leaders share how they leverage decades of institutional wisdom. The Greater Fayetteville Business Journal invites you to join us for our third quarterly Power Breakfast, The Fam
Skyeton leadership have decided to look locally for a general contractor to head up major renovations for the 28,479-square-foot building they’ve selected as their new home. Fayetteville-based Critical Path Solutions LLC has been chosen as the primary contractor for bringing new life to the previous Black+Decker plant site.
From left to right: US Secretary of Energy Chris Wright with Antares Co-founder and CEO Jordan Bramble. Photos courtesy of Antares Nuclear, Inc. Antares Nuclear, Inc. recently announced that it has been awarded an Other Transactions Authority ag
